• Rejected or didn't receive your confirmation email? Hit the Contact Us link at the bottom of any page to send us a message. We'll get you sorted. ~Jerk

Fuel quality and the onset of Ethanol

@Gamphy the only solution is right now 50:50 ratio of xp100 (E0) and regular petrol (e20) that gives makes it e10
Good shout, I'm lucky I don't need it with my ability to retune my ECU, but once E30 comes in, then things start to get a bit more interesting for anything older than 2024.
 
My grandmothers planted corn beans and squash together back when corn was an easily digestible protein. Something changed and corn hasn't been the same these last few centuries.

No one had studied what caused the change. If anybody figures that out.....

In other news the French may sprinkle a half teaspoon of corn to garnish a salad now and then but they don't eat corn as a side dish. However Southern France grows massive crops of corn every year. A little for feed but most for export to the distilleries in Ireland.
For some reason the site stopped sending me notifications about this thread, so I'm a bit behind...

Corn is a heavily-engineered species; people have been selectively breeding, crossing, and most recently genetically engineering it for centuries. One big goal has been to increase yield, in the sense of how many pounds of food each plant produces. A lot of this gain has come from making the individual kernels bigger. The trap in this strategy is that it leads to the same size embryo (the baby plant, where all the protein and fat are) and a bigger endosperm (the carbohydrate that serves as food for the baby plant). As a result, the nutritional balance in the kernel shifts from "reasonably good" to "empty calories."
 
For some reason the site stopped sending me notifications about this thread, so I'm a bit behind...

Corn is a heavily-engineered species; people have been selectively breeding, crossing, and most recently genetically engineering it for centuries. One big goal has been to increase yield, in the sense of how many pounds of food each plant produces. A lot of this gain has come from making the individual kernels bigger. The trap in this strategy is that it leads to the same size embryo (the baby plant, where all the protein and fat are) and a bigger endosperm (the carbohydrate that serves as food for the baby plant). As a result, the nutritional balance in the kernel shifts from "reasonably good" to "empty calories."
Yes, it is bio engineered for yield, growing season, ease of harvest, and pest resistance. I like eating stuff that eats the corn, but not so much the corn it's self.
 
Good shout, I'm lucky I don't need it with my ability to retune my ECU, but once E30 comes in, then things start to get a bit more interesting for anything older than 2024.
So the government is indirectly legislating older vehicles off the road by mandating fuels they can't burn? Well that sucks. The US government has kinda done that, but nowhere near as aggressively--they mandated unleaded gas starting in 1975, but only for new vehicles. Leaded didn't completely disappear until 1996. E10 is pretty much unavoidable in my home state of Illinois, though E0 is still available in much of the country (including the very corn-intensive states of Nebraska and Iowa, who apparently want everybody else to use their corn but want the option of not using it themselves).
 
Yes, it is bio engineered for yield, growing season, ease of harvest, and pest resistance. I like eating stuff that eats the corn, but not so much the corn it's self.
I like eating stuff that eats the corn too (I am an unrepentant carnivore). I also like sweet corn on the cob from time to time (sweet corn--the stuff intended for human consumption--is different from feed corn, the stuff fed to our food, and makes up only a tiny part of the overall corn crop). What I'm less enthusiastic about is the way corn has become the equivalent of crude oil in the way it's broken down into chemical feedstocks like HFCS and recombined into all sorts of artificial food-like substances. It's almost impossible to get away from corn-derived ingredients in any kind of processed food in the USA.
 
India just rolled out E85, Maruti Suzuki ( Suzuki cars made in India) announced a new flex fuel car and Hero Honda ( the world's largest motorcycle manufacturer) also brought out 2 flex fuel motorcycles.
Indians are very price sensitive, its 20% cheaper than E20 ( the current norm), so when they see cost per litre reduced by 20% they are thinking win win, but they haven't figured out yet that the running cost using E85 fuel is around 20%-25% less mileage.
 
India just rolled out E85, Maruti Suzuki ( Suzuki cars made in India) announced a new flex fuel car and Hero Honda ( the world's largest motorcycle manufacturer) also brought out 2 flex fuel motorcycles.
Indians are very price sensitive, its 20% cheaper than E20 ( the current norm), so when they see cost per litre reduced by 20% they are thinking win win, but they haven't figured out yet that the running cost using E85 fuel is around 20%-25% less mileage.
The thing is, the planet will be just fine long after humans are extinct. All that CO2 being released was in the atmosphere at one time or another, sometimes at much greater concentrations than now. Higher CO2 levels help whatever it is they are growing for the ethanol to grow faster. Greenhouses inject CO2 into the air to improve plant growth. Makes for happy healthy looking plants for sale.
The greatest "climate driver" besides the sun is water vapor, but you can't tax that, or trade it as a commodity, ensuring those in the loop will have all the credits they need. It's all so tiresome.
 
India just rolled out E85, Maruti Suzuki ( Suzuki cars made in India) announced a new flex fuel car and Hero Honda ( the world's largest motorcycle manufacturer) also brought out 2 flex fuel motorcycles.
Indians are very price sensitive, its 20% cheaper than E20 ( the current norm), so when they see cost per litre reduced by 20% they are thinking win win, but they haven't figured out yet that the running cost using E85 fuel is around 20%-25% less mileage.
Just a couple of corrections, its Hero Motorcorp, not been Hero Honda since 2011. Hero are the world's largest manufacturer of two-wheelers (motorcycles and scooters) in terms of unit volume sold by a single company in a year, a distinction it has held for more than 20 consecutive years, but Honda in terms of worldwide manufacturing and its joint ventures in different countries shifts 3 times more, but its a series of partnerships not a single company, thats why Hero make their claim, even so, they do sell over 6 million bikes per year.
 
Chemistry is not my strongest, but I don't get it:

-burning E0 is bad for the environment (I think we all know this).
-Ethanol is a little less bad.
-IF adding x% Ethanol really means mileage decreases with near x%...
-then there's defacto little reduction of the gas we burn, but on top of that we're burning Ethanol.
-conclusion would then be that adding Ethanol word be much worse for the environment.

What am I missing?
If this is true it's hard to believe all governments worldwide are doing this.
 
Exiting out of your vehicles tailpipe, Ethanol contains oxygen, which allows for a more complete combustion ( less power per litre, but better burn). This significantly reduces toxic exhaust emissions like carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, and exhaust hydrocarbons. So burning ethanol or a percentage thereof in lieu of petrol is cleaner.
But....While the act of burning ethanol is cleaner, producing it from crops (like corn) requires energy, water, and fertilizers, causing debate over whether the overall greenhouse gas (GHG) savings outweigh the energy used to produce it....the jury is very much out at the moment with many oil producers pushing their own agendas.
The reality of ethanol being added to fuel is because its cheaper than oil, so countries that don't have their own oil and rely on imports see adding ethanol as a way to reduce their costs, India being a prime example.
To answer your question, based on emissions per litre, because ethanol has a higher hydrogen-to-carbon ratio than pure petrol, burning a litre of E20 petrol generates roughly 6.6% to 7% less carbon dioxide (CO₂) than a litre of pure E0 petrol.
But...since E20 delivers 7% less mileage, your vehicle must burn roughly 7.5% more fuel to travel the exact same distance.
So, the net impact per mile based on the 7% volume emission advantage is mathematically neutralized by the 7.5% increase in fuel consumption. As a result, the tailpipe CO₂ emitted into the air per mile driven remains practically identical.
In conclusion, both E0 and E20, based on the burn efficiency per mile emit about the same CO₂, but in theory E20 should be cheaper to buy, as long as you don't factor in the costs of corrosion and potential fuel separation issues.
 
The original “environmental” claim made for ethanol is that it combusted more fully and therefore reduced hydrocarbon and nitrogen oxide emissions, which were the definition of “pollution” until people started paying attention to what Arrhenius had observed almost a century before, that moving carbon from underground (coal, oil, gas) into the atmosphere as CO2 would change the climate. Then ethanol was retconned into a way to reduce fossil fuel CO2 emissions because the carbon in corn ethanol and other biofuels comes from plants trapped atmospheric CO2. This is at best only partially true: corn in particular requires fertilizer, and ethanol needs to be distilled, both of which consume natural gas. Some have done the math and concluded that corn ethanol is equivalent (in terms of CO2 emissions) to just using natural gas as motor fuel.

Another claim made for ethanol back in the early days was “energy independence.” Remember that the Arab oil embargo of 1973 seriously inconvenienced millions of American voters. Ethanol was part of the “home grown American fuel” movement that also included shale oil, Canadian tar sludge, and fracking. It was about not being pushed around by the Saudis and Iraqis, not about the environment.

This is what happens when you don’t have a coherent policy or program. The ethanol mandate is less an environmental or energy policy than a compromise between two of the biggest lobbying groups outside the defense [sic] industry, agriculture and petroleum.

Oh… and while it is true that the carbon in our underground coal, oil, and gas deposits was once in the atmosphere, the earth was not a pleasant place to live at that time. Look up “Permian Mass Extinction,” when the natural discharge of underground carbon into the atmosphere wiped out something like 97% of all species. Not fun at all.

Sorry about the overly long sentences. It’s what happens when I write on a phone.
 
The original “environmental” claim made for ethanol is that it combusted more fully and therefore reduced hydrocarbon and nitrogen oxide emissions, which were the definition of “pollution” until people started paying attention to what Arrhenius had observed almost a century before, that moving carbon from underground (coal, oil, gas) into the atmosphere as CO2 would change the climate. Then ethanol was retconned into a way to reduce fossil fuel CO2 emissions because the carbon in corn ethanol and other biofuels comes from plants trapped atmospheric CO2. This is at best only partially true: corn in particular requires fertilizer, and ethanol needs to be distilled, both of which consume natural gas. Some have done the math and concluded that corn ethanol is equivalent (in terms of CO2 emissions) to just using natural gas as motor fuel.

Another claim made for ethanol back in the early days was “energy independence.” Remember that the Arab oil embargo of 1973 seriously inconvenienced millions of American voters. Ethanol was part of the “home grown American fuel” movement that also included shale oil, Canadian tar sludge, and fracking. It was about not being pushed around by the Saudis and Iraqis, not about the environment.

This is what happens when you don’t have a coherent policy or program. The ethanol mandate is less an environmental or energy policy than a compromise between two of the biggest lobbying groups outside the defense [sic] industry, agriculture and petroleum.

Oh… and while it is true that the carbon in our underground coal, oil, and gas deposits was once in the atmosphere, the earth was not a pleasant place to live at that time. Look up “Permian Mass Extinction,” when the natural discharge of underground carbon into the atmosphere wiped out something like 97% of all species. Not fun at all.

Sorry about the overly long sentences. It’s what happens when I write on a phone.
The only coherent Ethanol policy was mandated by Brazil in 1975, when they started their increased ethanol production and started adding it to their petrol in 76, this was a direct result of the 73 fuel crisis and the fact they hadn't yet discovered their massive deep water oil fields, their car industry developed engines that could run 100% alcohol and by 1985 95% of all vehicles sold ran on 100% alcohol. It should be noted Brazil were able to switch to ethanol because of their huge over production of sugar cane.
But by the early 2000s the price of Ethanol was becoming very variable , this was caused by poor harvest conditions and the price of sugar ( some years it was more profitable to produce sugar instead of Ethanol), this coincided with Brazils increased oil production after their discovery of the deep water offshore oil fields, Brazil became oil self sufficient by 2006.
E22 was becoming more popular, although E100 was still very prevalent. Flex fuel cars became the norm, to take advantage of which fuel represented the best value.
By 2025 they had mandated E30 petrol with a possibility of E32 becoming the standard by 2026. Both E100 and E30 are still widely available and Flex fuel cars can take advantage of both.
Its important to note that Ethanol wasn't adopted because Brazil lacked oil entirely—it was adopted because imported oil was expensive and vulnerable to supply shocks, coupled with an extensive sugar cane production capability. Now that oil is available locally they seem to be slowing down ethanol production.
 
The original “environmental” claim made for ethanol is that it combusted more fully and therefore reduced hydrocarbon and nitrogen oxide emissions, which were the definition of “pollution” until people started paying attention to what Arrhenius had observed almost a century before, that moving carbon from underground (coal, oil, gas) into the atmosphere as CO2 would change the climate. Then ethanol was retconned into a way to reduce fossil fuel CO2 emissions because the carbon in corn ethanol and other biofuels comes from plants trapped atmospheric CO2. This is at best only partially true: corn in particular requires fertilizer, and ethanol needs to be distilled, both of which consume natural gas. Some have done the math and concluded that corn ethanol is equivalent (in terms of CO2 emissions) to just using natural gas as motor fuel.

Another claim made for ethanol back in the early days was “energy independence.” Remember that the Arab oil embargo of 1973 seriously inconvenienced millions of American voters. Ethanol was part of the “home grown American fuel” movement that also included shale oil, Canadian tar sludge, and fracking. It was about not being pushed around by the Saudis and Iraqis, not about the environment.

This is what happens when you don’t have a coherent policy or program. The ethanol mandate is less an environmental or energy policy than a compromise between two of the biggest lobbying groups outside the defense [sic] industry, agriculture and petroleum.

Oh… and while it is true that the carbon in our underground coal, oil, and gas deposits was once in the atmosphere, the earth was not a pleasant place to live at that time. Look up “Permian Mass Extinction,” when the natural discharge of underground carbon into the atmosphere wiped out something like 97% of all species. Not fun at all.

Sorry about the overly long sentences. It’s what happens when I write on a phone.
I have been following the climate doom bullshit since the looming ice age predicted in the 70's. Not a single prediction by the "experts" has come true. Zero. It is more a control scheme to enrich certain classes and have the rest under their thumb. The aircraft that fly the expensive hookers to the climate conferences in places like Bali or tahiti expend more co2 for that trip than I do in a couple of years.
You would think all those people so concerned about the climate would hold these conferences electronically to "save the planet", but there is no luxury vacation paid for by someone else when you do that.
The greatest climate driver of all is the sun. Without it, there would be no earth. It affects the climate way more that a trace gas making up less than 1% of the atmosphere that just happens to be the only thing they can use as an economic weapon.
 
Top Bottom